Source: Delco Times
By: John Grisham
In October 2024, I published “Framed,” a collection of 10 outrageous stories of wrongful convictions.
Jim McCloskey, my co-writer, and I decided to include one case that is not yet over, a case in which thewrongfully accused are still in prison and fighting to get out.
We chose the story, called “Unknown Male Number One,” about the corrupt convictions and imprisonment of Samuel Grasty, Derrick Chappell and Morton Johnson.
The Chester Trio, as they are sometimes known, have now been in prison for 26 years for a crime they had nothing to do with.
In a nutshell, the case involved the sexual assault, beating and murder of an elderly woman in Chester.
The crime scene yielded an abundance of evidence that clearly pointed to a suspect the police have never caught. He left behind blood, semen and sweat, not to mention a jacket.
Undeniable DNA testing excluded Grasty, Chappell and Johnson, but the police arrested them anyway, then handed them over to the district attorney who managed to string together enough unreliable and downright fraudulent evidence to get convictions.
All three trials were shams and would have been comical but for the devastating results.
The police and prosecutors ignored not only the DNA testing but all manner of common sense, and relied upon the ever-shifting, even hallucinogenic testimony of a mentally challenged 15-year-old drug addict who told half a dozen different versions of his lies during the trials.
In 1999, the Chester Trio were sent to prison, where they remain.
A flicker of hope emerged two years ago when Judge Mary Ann Brennan of the Court of Common Pleas vacated the guilty verdicts and ordered new trials.
For a moment it seemed as if this injustice might finally come to an end. However, the three are still waiting.
The search for truth and justice is often stymied by the very people elected to uphold it. And nothing frightens a prosecutor more than the likelihood that a corrupt and bogus conviction is about to be exposed.
It is not at all uncommon for prosecutors to circle the wagons, fight efforts to obtain DNA testing, cling to discredited evidence and witnesses, continue to trumpet guilt, and delay at every turn.
The district attorney for Delaware County could have accepted Judge Brennan’s decision, which was amply supported by the law and the facts, and either agreed to new trials, or simply dismissed the cases.
He did neither.
Instead, he stuck to the DA’s playbook and appealed the decision, thus guaranteeing more wasted time in prison for Grasty, Johnson and Chappell.
They are stuck there.
Meanwhile, the DA has been elevated to a judgeship on the Court of Common Pleas.
Why is the District Attorney’s Office afraid of new trials? The answer is obvious: It can’t win them!
The proof 26 years ago was virtually nonexistent. The proof today does not exist.
Taking another page from the playbook, the DA sought to get rid of the cases by offering a typical, backdoor deal: If each of the three would plead guilty, they would be released for time served.
Imagine the temptation of walking out of prison after 26 years!
But each of the three refused to lie and said no.
Samuel Grasty, Derrick Chappell and Morton Johnson were innocent as teenagers, and they remain innocent as middle age approaches and they wait and wait for a decision on the DA’s appeal.